Free printable jar tags — make a simmer pot kit this weekend

Thanksgiving Simmer Pot – Cranberry, Apple and Spice

Cranberries being harvested in a flooded bog

TL;DR

Cranberries, apple, orange, cinnamon and cloves, simmered on low. Top up the water, and turn the pot off before you leave the room.

Thanksgiving simmer pot recipe

This is the stovetop scent people put on for Thanksgiving: cranberry, apple and orange with cinnamon and clove. It is a smelling pot, not a drink.

Dried orange slices, cinnamon sticks, star anise and whole cloves on a wooden table

Add the fruit and spice

Put the cranberries, apple, orange, cinnamon sticks and cloves in a small saucepan with about 3 cups of water.

Simmer on low

Bring it to a bare simmer, then keep the heat low for two to three hours. Top the water up when the level drops, and never let the pot boil dry.

Cool and reuse

Turn the burner off before you leave the house or go to sleep. Refrigerate the mixture and reheat it gently the next day. Replace the fruit when it turns mushy.

Timing it around the turkey

The mistake most hosts make is putting the pot on at the same time as the turkey. Both compete for the same small kitchen and the same nose, and a pot set at noon is one you stop noticing by the time anyone arrives. Work it the other way round and time the scent to the guest instead of the bird.

Prep it ahead, keep it clean

Set the cinnamon sticks and whole cloves in the saucepan the night before with the lid on, and slice the fruit in the morning. Cut apple and orange go soft overnight, and soft fruit breaks down into cloudy water within an hour of simmering.

Leftovers keep in the fridge for about a day: strain the fruit out, keep the liquid, reheat it gently the next morning. Past that, throw it out. Water with fruit and spice in it grows mould quickly at room temperature, and a pot left on the stove overnight is one of the more common small kitchen mishaps of the holiday.

Make it your own

A sprig of rosemary is a common extra and does not change the method. Keep the cranberries, apple and orange as the base. For the earlier autumn version, use the fall cranberry simmer pot. When you want pine in the pot, switch to the Christmas simmer pot. The water, heat and refill rules are the same ones on the base simmer pot recipe.

Stovetop, water, fire, pet, and child notes are on the simmer pot safety page.

Our recommended picks

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links marked as sponsored — a qualifying purchase may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Recommended #1

Simmer pot spice kit

Cinnamon sticks and whole cloves, pre-measured for a holiday pot.

View product
Recommended

Small stainless steel saucepan with lid

A small lidded pot that holds a low simmer without running dry as fast.

View product
Recommended

Dried orange slices

Citrus that keeps its shape when fresh oranges are already used up.

View product

More recipes

Frequently asked questions

What goes in a Thanksgiving simmer pot?

Cranberries, apple, orange, cinnamon sticks and whole cloves, covered with water. A sprig of rosemary is a common optional extra. Keep the heat low.

How long should a Thanksgiving simmer pot run?

Two to three hours on low is the usual window. Top up the water as it drops, and turn the burner off before you leave the house or go to sleep.

Can I use frozen cranberries?

Yes. Frozen cranberries go into the pot the same way fresh ones do.

Can I use a slow cooker instead of the stove?

Yes. A slow cooker on low gives the same gentle heat and needs less watching. Still turn it off before you leave or go to sleep.

When should I start a Thanksgiving simmer pot?

Two to three hours before guests arrive. The scent is strongest in the first hour or so, and a pot started at noon is one nobody notices by the time people walk in.

Can I prep it the night before?

Prep the dry parts — cinnamon sticks and whole cloves — and leave them in the pot with the lid on. Slice the apple and orange the same morning, because cut fruit softens and loses its edge overnight.

Will the scent last through dinner?

Water evaporates faster while a turkey is roasting, so check the level every 45 to 60 minutes. Turn the pot off when you sit down to eat and bring it back to a bare simmer for coffee and pie.

Is a Thanksgiving simmer pot for drinking?

No. This is a stovetop scent pot, the same kind as the other recipes on this site. Do not serve it as a drink.

Is it safe around pets?

Keep the pot out of reach and never leave it where a cat or dog can drink from it — the water carries clove and citrus. If you want to add essential oils, check the pet notes on the <a href="/simmer-pot-essential-oils/">essential oils page</a> first, since several common oils are flagged for cats.

Image credits

Credited images are third-party photographs used under the licence named beside each one. Images without a credit line are original to this site.